Original Sin Is A Lie by Bob Peck

You were never broken.

If someone sent you here, they probably care about you, and they probably know you've been sitting with some questions. That's a good sign.

Nobody here is asking you to leave anything. Not your church, not your people, and definitely not Jesus. He's worth sincere contemplation. So are the questions. This page is a quiet place to start, with a book, its main ideas in plain language, and some good company for the road.

A hand holding a copy of Original Sin Is A Lie in front of a crape myrtle in full pink bloom
Cover of Original Sin Is A Lie by Bob Peck: a glowing orb of yellow, teal, violet and pink on white
The book

Original Sin Is A Lie

How Spirituality Defies Dogma and Reveals Our True Self

I was raised an Easter-and-Christmas Christian in Texas, studied the New Testament at the University of Texas, and have spent twenty years reading the mystics of every tradition. This book is what came out of all that: the history of how the church got some things wrong, and why the man from Nazareth is more beautiful than the institution that grew up around him.

The digital bundle includes the ebook, the audiobook, the Spanish edition, and the study guide.

Portada de El Pecado Original Es Mentira
También en español

El Pecado Original Es Mentira

Traducido por Marcelo S. Villaseñor, Bryan G. Olivas-Orozco y Alejandro Jiménez-Cuervo.

The short version

Seven ideas at the heart of the book

Every one of these is sourced and footnoted in the book. None of them asks you to love Jesus any less.

  1. Original sin isn't in Genesis.

    The word sin doesn't appear in the Garden story, and Judaism, the tradition that wrote Genesis, has never taught it. The doctrine took shape with Augustine around 400 CE, nearly four centuries after Jesus.

  2. Sin meant missing the mark.

    The Greek word is hamartia, an archer's term. Not a permanent stain on the soul. You aimed, you missed, you aim again.

  3. Repent means change your mind.

    Jesus' word was metanoia, literally "beyond the mind." A call to see differently, not a sentence of lifelong shame.

  4. The kingdom is within you.

    Luke 17:21. The Greek entos points inward. The kingdom isn't a place you get let into later. It's already here, underneath the noise.

  5. Hell has a history.

    The word Jesus used most was Gehenna, a real valley outside Jerusalem with a dark past. The pitchforks and eternal torture came much later, from preachers and painters.

  6. The Bible was gathered by people.

    The earliest gospel was written about forty years after the crucifixion, and scholars agree on only seven of the letters signed by Paul. Knowing how the book was assembled can deepen faith rather than end it.

  7. All paths can get you there.

    The mystics of every tradition, Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, Sufi, Jewish, Taoist, keep pointing at the same thing: that every being is equally Beloved, and nothing can separate us from The Divine.

The Flammarion engraving: a pilgrim kneels at the edge of the world and pushes his head through the starry sky to see the wheels and fire beyond it
The Flammarion engraving, from Camille Flammarion's L'atmosphère (1888). A pilgrim reaches the place where the sky meets the earth and looks through.
"It is we who have put our hands over our eyes and cry that it is dark!" Swami Vivekananda
Read it with someone

The Companion

A study guide and journal for reading the book alone or in a small group. Twenty chapters of anchors, journal prompts, and ways to take it further, plus group agreements and session plans for six, twelve, or twenty-one weeks. Good for a friend, a cousin, a Sunday school class that likes the hard questions.

Where to go next

Keep reading, keep listening

Free

The Seeker's Reading List

The books that shaped this one, across every tradition, with notes on where to start.

Essay

The Birth of Christ in You

Jesus as big brother of humanity, and what the Second Coming might really mean.

Essay

A Psychedelic Christian at an Art Gallery

On "born again" as a mystical symbol, and the backflips of the only-way crowd.

Podcast

Christianity: The Beauty and Confusion

A long conversation with Aubrey Marcus on original sin, Augustine, and keeping Jesus close.

Video

Bob Peck on YouTube

Excerpts from the book, meditations, conversations, and documentaries.

Substack

Original Sin Is A Lie & More From the Spiritual Buffet Line

Every essay, from hell as a state of mind to the mystics who stood up to kings.

Good company

Communities and teachers worth your time

You don't have to walk this alone, and you don't have to walk away from Christianity to walk it.

Christian contemplative

Center for Action and Contemplation

Richard Rohr's home for Christian mysticism. Free daily meditations by email.

Practice

Contemplative Outreach

Thomas Keating's centering prayer, with groups that meet all over the world.

East meets West

Self-Realization Fellowship

Paramahansa Yogananda's teachings, including his reading of the Gospels as a mystic.

The history

Bart Ehrman

A leading New Testament scholar who writes for regular people about how the Bible came to be.